Rendering plant licence annulled in Doninos, Salamanca, Spain, but odour problem remains unresolved

Image: salamancartvaldia.es

   This is a familiar story. An Activity Potentially Causing Odour Nuisance (APCON), in this case a rendering plant, affects a local community for years. In Doñinos de Salamanca, the plant processing fats and animal by-products is operated by Servcor Logistics, S.L.U., part of the Bioscor group. Residents of Villamayor and other localities in the Alfoz have been reporting episodes of odour for years and calling for an effective response. After numerous protests and a response that residents consider inadequate, the dispute ends up in court. But the judgment addresses issues other than the one that prompted the protests: living with the odour day to day.

   The lack of specific, consistent regulation on odour contributes to situations like this dragging on. This does not mean there are no legal avenues or technical tools available: environmental and planning conditions can apply, and there are methods for measuring odour. However, the lack of common criteria can make it difficult to assess the nuisance, identify its source and determine what measures are needed. As a result, court proceedings may end up focusing on aspects other than the impact that concerns residents most.

   That is what happened with the planning permission for the Doñinos plant. The court quashed it because of breaches relating to the exceptional-use authorisation granted in 2000, including the requirement to register the land-use restriction and the limit on the proportion of the plot that could be occupied. The judgment states that the council knew of these breaches when it granted permission to regularise works that had already been carried out. However, the ruling does not determine the source or intensity of the odour reported by residents, nor does it set out measures to control it.

   The Cuidamos Villamayor Platform has for years brought together residents’ complaints and calls for action. Their demands go beyond clarifying the planning situation: they want the impact of the odour investigated and inspection findings, proceedings and any measures taken by the authorities to be communicated transparently. Although the judgment requires Doñinos Council to restore planning compliance, it does not, by itself, resolve those demands.

   The case is also shaped by a possible change of ownership. SARIA Bio-Industries España announced an agreement to acquire 100% of Bioscor, the group to which Servcor Logistics belongs. According to the published reports, the deal was awaiting approval from the Spanish National Commission on Markets and Competition. The possible change of ownership makes it all the more important that environmental obligations and control measures remain in place and are enforced.

   In 2026, following further episodes of odour, the Regional Government of Castile and León inspected the plant and opened a new sanctions proceeding. Villamayor Council requested access to the inspection reports and information on the environmental proceedings. These are significant steps, but they do not yet amount to a solution: the findings will need to be made known, and it will be necessary to establish whether the measures taken effectively prevent further nuisance.

   The Doñinos judgment highlights the gap between what a court can decide in a particular case and what the affected community needs addressed. Planning permission can be quashed for breaches without the complaint about odour being resolved. While clear criteria and a specific assessment are lacking, residents may continue to face uncertainty about how the nuisance is assessed, who should act and what measures can be required.

   The case should not, therefore, end with the restoration of planning compliance. It also requires an assessment of the impact of the odour, transparent access to the findings and effective measures where appropriate. If the change of ownership goes ahead, the new owner will need to comply with its obligations and address a problem that has affected daily life in Villamayor and other localities in the Alfoz for years. SARIA’s possible arrival also raises questions and expectations. As a multinational with greater financial and technical resources than a local operator, it may be better placed to invest in modernising the facilities and implementing measures to prevent and control odour.

   In any case, this is the same old story: an APCON affects a local community and, as is often the case where there is no specific odour legislation, the judge rules on other matters because there is no clear basis on which to decide the main issue: the impact of the odour. This has happened in many APCON cases in Spain, involving other rendering plants, paper mills, wastewater treatment plants and similar facilities. Some have avoided conflict by tackling the underlying problem; others have not.

 

Article prepared with the assistance of AI.


  If you found this article interesting, you may also be interested in:

 

 

All the content here under Creative Commons license